Level Up Your Christmas Cookie Game with these Santa Coal Cookie Tags

Level Up Your Christmas Cookie Game with these Santa Coal Cookie Tags

Give someone on your naughty list the gift of Christmas cheer this year by surprising them with delicious homemade coal cookies and unique Santa-themed sticker labels.

Christmas cookies are a staple in many homes during the holidays, and upping your cookie decorating game with these Santa Coal Cookie Tags will be sure to put a smile on everyone's face. Not only do these tags add a unique touch to your favorite holiday treats, but they also make for an adorable surprise for Santa! Let's take a look at what you need to make these festive cookie gifts.

Step-by-Step: How to gift cute coal cookies with cool packaging ideas

In this guide you will learn:

  • A delicious peppermint chocolate cookie recipe for baking coal cookies
  • Where to get the best lump of coal cookie cutter design
  • An easy technique for that stunning authentic coal look
  • Cute ideas on packaging items so your finished cookies will be totally #Instaworthy!

Step 1: Use the Best Roll Out Sugar Cookie Recipe

Peppermint Mocha Cookie Recipe

You can use any roll out cookie recipe for these coal cookies, but my go-to choice would be Semi Sweet Mike's delicious Peppermint Mocha Cookie recipe. It combines decadent chocolatey flavors, an energizing espresso kick and a cool peppermint finish—tastes just like those yummy Girl Scout Thin Mints but redesigned for the holidays! You can use the creamy Andes peppermint crunch baking chips or leave them out for a consistent shade of dark chocolate goodness.

Coal sugar cookies using Semi Sweet Mike's peppermint mocha cookie recipe

Step 2: Cut your dough with a lump of coal cookie cutter from Semi Sweet Designs

Now that you have your favorite cookie dough recipe, it’s time to create the perfect coal-shape cookie with our lump of coal cookie cutter. We designed this cookie cutter to have the fun design and to cut out your sugar cookie dough with ease. Get yours and other Christmas cookie cutter designs in our shop.

Lump of coal cookie cutter from Semi Sweet Designs

Step 3: Use the crumbled parchment cookie decorating tutorial

OK, now it's time to get creative with royal icing! The struggle of getting the perfect coal texture can be frustrating but with Mike's coal decorating tutorial, you'll be able to master the crumble parchment paper technique for beautiful coal babies each time. This technique gives your royal icing a beautiful coal-like texture – perfect for a sharp aesthetic. All you need is royal icing and some parchment paper - you’ll be making something special in very little time!

Crumbled parchment cookie decorating tutorial

Step 4: Assemble cute cookie packaging items

Black Resealable Gift Bag

Now that your coal cookies have been lovingly crafted, it's time to finish off the gift bag packaging. We use simple resealable black bags on Amazon, making sure each one is carefully filled and packed in a way that will wow your recipient! The clear window in the front will help show off your beautiful cookies inside.

Resealable black gift bags

Kringle's Coal Co. Sticker Tag Labels

Last but certainly not least, let's talk about one of the most eye-catching features of our cookie bags—our Kringle's Coal Co. sticker labels! I designed these stickers to give your cookie bags the extra touch that will truly make them stand out. These sticker labels come in packs of 25 and are the perfect way to add a pop of holiday cheer to your gift bags. Level up your presentation and go from good to great with our Kringle's Coal Co. sticker labels!

If you're looking for an easy yet festive cookie gift to make this holiday season, give these Christmas coal cookies a try. They're perfect for beginners or anyone short on time, and are sure to put a smile on even the grinchiest of faces.